Featured Stories World News Commentary Money Watch Multimedia Prison Planet U.S. News Science And Technology

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors

  • Print The Alex Jones Channel Alex Jones Show podcast Prison Planet TV Infowars.com Twitter Alex Jones' Facebook Infowars store

Watts Up With That?
April 24, 2010

UPDATE: I’ve been in contact with the Eureka Weather Station manager, and despite the incredible nature of the temperature jumps that are outside of normal experiences, such as July 14 2009,  they do appear to be real. The METAR coding errors are another issue. I have many pictures now, plus a plan map, and a better meteorological insight than what can be gained from the meager online metadata. I’ll have an updated post later tonight or tomorrow – Anthony

Ecotretas find more cases of missing “M”s and mangled data in METAR reports making it into climatic temperature data.  I’ve reposted his findings below and added some of my own notes [in brackets] to strengthen his findings. This time it’s Eureka, Nunavut, Canada. From “Up Here” magazine:

The first High Arctic Weather Station in history, Eureka was established in April 1947 at 80-degrees north latitude in the vicinity of two rivers, which provided fresh water to the six-man United States Army Air Force team that parachuted in. They erected Jamesway huts to shelter themselves and their equipment until August, when an icebreaker reached Eureka – as it has every year since – and brought permanent buildings and supplies. For decades after that, small, all-male crews would hunker down for entire winters, going a little stir-crazy from the isolation.

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors 332142726 532a324a81 Photo by Eric Charlton from Flicker used under creative commons license 

As I pointed out last Saturday there’s a common reporting flaw in world meteorological stations that use the METAR weather data format to report their hourly temperatures. Just one bad report in a cold location in the Arctic or Antarctic is enough to throw off the whole month’s worth of data when averaged. And it is monthly data that is used for climate. The all time high temperature error identified below has found it’s way into Wikipedia as “factual” when it is clearly wrong.

  • A d v e r t i s e m e n t

Some METAR and other kinds of unidentified errors also seem to be finding their way into official Environment Canada data. I’ve made screencaps. Given the importance of this weather station as the last surviving  GHCN station that far north, also used in GISS, you’d think better quality control would be done, particularly when EC has a statement about data quality on each data page. What has been found seems to point to a corrupted dataset there.

- Anthony

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors 150410banner1

=======================================

Eureka by Ecotretas

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors GHCN GISS 250km Anom03 2010 2010 1951 1980

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors GHCN GISS 1200km Anom03 2010 2010 1951 1980

[Images above from GISS - click to enlarge]

Eureka, in Nunavut Canada, is a very special meteorological station. As can be seen in the first image above, it is responsible for the very big stripe on the very top of Canada. As can be seen on the second image, the data from only one station is responsible for a very big percentage of global temperatures… Both graphs can be obtained here.

So, one would imagine that data for this station is quality proof. We found two sources for temperature data: at Weather Underground and at the National Climate Data and Information Archive.

The first interesting data about this station is its record high temperature, which according to Wikipedia was reached on July 14, 2009, with 20ºC. [image below added by Anthony]

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors screencap from Wikipedia’s climate section on Eureka station -click to enlarge 

 

[UPDATE: Wikipedia editor removed the sentence above within 8 hours of this posting. See discussion here]

On Weather Underground, the monthly page for that day does say that 20ºC was the maximum temperature. But when you check the METAR data, the maximum temperature was 14ºC.

[Here is where it really gets strange, I've added two screencaps from Environment Canada, on for the monthly data, another for the daily data from July 14th, 2009. They don't match! The 20.9C value never appears in the July 14th hourly data. Click images below to enlarge, EC's July 2009 Monthly report on the left, July 14th, 2009 daily/hourly data on the right. Perhaps EC corrected the error in the daily/hourly data, but missed the monthly?  - Anthony]

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors

[click images above to enlarge]

[It also shows up as 20.9C on the EC yearly report for 2009, shown below]

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors

Checking the Environment Canada page, the maximum for the date was 14.4ºC.

Things were different on the day before, July 13th. Maximum temperature for Weather Underground was also 20ºC, while at Environment Canada was 19.6ºC. But if you check the graphs below, some special heat occurred at 10PM, when temperatures soared some 15ºC!

(click images to enlarge)

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors wu 20090713

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors env20090713

[Image below added by Anthony. Here is the METAR report for Eureka, via Weather Underground, the error is highlighted in yellow, note the jump in temperature followed by a fall the next hour]

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors Eureka METAR coded and decoded 07-13-09 click to enlarge 

[In the image below added by Anthony, note the implausible temperature jump in the Environment Canada data for July 13th, 2009 at 22:00 where it was 5.9C at 21:00, jumping to 19.6C at 22:00, then back down to 4.1C at 23:00. Looking at the weather conditions of clear sky and moderate sustained winds from the North ~ 24 km/hr, there does not appear to be a meteorological explanation. Looking at the METAR data above, it appears the temperature was rounded up by the observer to 20C from 19.6. This makes me wonder if the event could be caused by something like a plane, truck, or snow-cat parked briefly near the sensor. In the Arctic, vehicles are left to idle, as turning them off allows them to freeze up, sometimes never to be restarted. ]

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors

As Anthony Watts pointed out at Watts Up With That, the Eureka station registered the biggest rise in temperature probably seen on the Earth’s surface: 86ºC in one hour, on March 3, 2007! Now this data is available on Weather Underground, but seems not to exist in Environment Canada. The graph differences are clear below:

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors wu 20070303

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors env20070303

But that seems not to be the case in other examples. Take January 1st, 2007, for instance. Both Weather Underground and Environment Canada agree: there was a mighty spike at noon. Seems like the “M” problem affects both:

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors wu 20070101

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors env20070101

[Here's the METAR data with the missing "M", note at  11AM the M reappears]

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors

There are times where differences are not so big, but the “M” problem is still there. Check the images from Weather Underground and Environment Canada for September 26, 2006:

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors wu 20060926

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors env20060926

Other times, changes are so significant, that something must be wrong. Check out the temperature rise on June 20, 2005. On the left, the weekly graph from Weather Underground shows a great surge in temperatures, confirmed by the Environment Canada graph for the day.

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors wu 20050620

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors env20050620

=====================================

Thanks to Ecotretas for his sleuthing, I’m sure there are many more like this yet to be discovered. It seems with Eureka, more is going on than METAR errors. The temperature rises reported seem impossible given the meteorological conditions, and because they seem to be automated, suggest sensor error or perhaps sensor environment contamination (like a vehicle or other heat source). If you look at this 1997 image from Wikipedia (and click it to get the super hi-res version and pan around) you’ll see a number of vehicles near buildings. Where is the temperature sensor? – I don’t know, but if someone can find out it might shed some light on this mystery.

Dial “M” for mangled – Wikipedia and Environment Canada caught with temperature data errors 800px Eureka Weather Station 1997 08 04

The fact that the obvious error on July 14th is now cited in Wikipedia as an “all time record high”, when it doesn’t appear in the EC hourly data, is troubling. – Anthony

This article was posted: Saturday, April 24, 2010 at 3:32 am





Infowars.com Videos:

Comment on this article

Comments are closed.

Watch the News

FEATURED VIDEOS
Whistleblower: Ukrainian Troops Shot Down MH17 See the rest on the Alex Jones YouTube channel.

The World Is Cruising Toward Nuclear War See the rest on the Alex Jones YouTube channel.

© 2013 PrisonPlanet.com is a Free Speech Systems, LLC company. All rights reserved. Digital Millennium Copyright Act Notice.