Search  About Salon  Table Talk  Advertise in Salon  Investor Relations

salon premiumfind out morelogin

[Arts & Entertainment][ Books ][ Comics ][ Life ][ News ][ People ][ Politics ][ Sex ][ Technology ][ Audio ]

Article Finder
Salon News



- - - - - - - - - - - -

Time to torture?
Americans are debating whether torture should be used against terrorists. But the case of Israel shows that brutality in the name of morality doesn't pay.

- - - - - - - - - - - -
By Flore de Préneuf

Nov. 16, 2001 | JERUSALEM -- It's a classic moral dilemma: Imagine security services know a bomb is about to blow up in a crowded public space, killing and maiming possibly hundreds of people. But the plot can only be foiled if information is violently extracted from a tight-lipped terrorist suspect. What should you do?

As Americans grapple with the possibility of ticking time-bomb scenarios in the wake of Sept. 11, the once-unthinkable is being openly talked about: torture. In a column titled "Time to Think About Torture," liberal Newsweek columnist Jonathan Alter mused whether torture would "jump-start the stalled investigation into the greatest crime in American history." Alan Dershowitz, normally known as a staunch civil libertarian, told Newsweek: "I’m not in favor of torture, but if you’re going to have it, it should damn well have court approval."

Amid these calls to begin debating a practice formerly condemned by all sides as barbaric -- not to mention the Bush administration's plan to try suspected terrorists in military courts, where they would have far fewer rights -- it is worth examining Israel's experience. The Jewish state has been using torture for decades against Palestinians. And its experience should serve as a powerful warning against the temptation to use brutal interrogation methods.
- - - - - - - - - - - -

premiumWant to read more? This article is Salon Premium content and only available to subscribers. Find out more or if you're already a member log in here.

Why should you join Salon Premium?

•  Exclusive content, including nearly all of our award-winning news and politics coverage, as well as other special features, like an expanded Friday edition of "Nothing Personal," weekly serials like "Nancy Chan: Diary of a Manhattan Call Girl" and more.

•  Exclusive services, like the option to view Salon without banners and pop-up ads and the ability to download a day's worth of Salon content as a simple text or PDF file.

•  Exclusive audio downloads like the audio book of "F. Scott Fitzgerald's Short Stories" (retail value: $35).

Find out more or subscribe now.


Salon Politics: Unflinching daily political news, analysis and commentary.

Salon  Search  About Salon  Table Talk  Advertise in Salon  Investor Relations

Arts & Entertainment | Books | Comics | Life | News | People
Politics | Sex | Tech & Business and The Free Software Project | Audio
Letters | Columnists | Salon Plus | Salon Gear

Reproduction of material from any Salon pages without written permission is strictly prohibited
Copyright 2003
Salon, 22 4th Street, 16th Floor, San Francisco, CA 94103
Telephone 415 645-9200 | Fax 415 645-9204
E-mail | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service