Featured Stories
World News
Commentary
Money Watch
Multimedia
Prison Planet
U.S. News
Science And Technology

Watts Up With That?

Sunday, Dec 27th, 2009

Physicist Luboš Motl of The Reference Frame demonstrates how easy it is to show that there is: No statistically significant warming since 1995

First, since it wasn’t in his original post, here is the UAH data plotted:

**By: Luboš Motl**

Because there has been some confusion – and maybe deliberate confusion – among some (alarmist) commenters about the non-existence of a statistically significant warming trend since 1995, i.e. in the last fifteen years, let me dedicate a full article to this issue.

I will use the UAH temperatures whose final 2009 figures are de facto known by now (with a sufficient accuracy) because UAH publishes the daily temperatures, too:

Mathematica can calculate the confidence intervals for the slope (warming trend) by concise commands. But I will calculate the standard error of the slope manually.

x = Table[i, {i, 1995, 2009}] y = {0.11, 0.02, 0.05, 0.51, 0.04, 0.04, 0.2, 0.31, 0.28, 0.19, 0.34, 0.26, 0.28, 0.05, 0.26}; data = Transpose[{x, y}](**) n = 15 xAV = Total[x]/n yAV = Total[y]/n xmav = x - xAV; ymav = y - yAV; lmf = LinearModelFit[data, xvar, xvar]; Normal[lmf](**) (* http://stattrek.com/AP-Statistics-4/Estimate-Slope.aspx?Tutorial=AP *) ;slopeError = Sqrt[Total[ymav^2]/(n - 2)]/Sqrt[Total[xmav^2]]

The UAH 1995-2009 slope was calculated to be 0.95 °C per century. And the standard deviation of this figure, calculated via the standard formula on this page, is 0.88 °C/century. So this suggests that the positivity of the slope is just a 1-sigma result – a noise. Can we be more rigorous about it? You bet.

Mathematica actually has compact functions that can tell you the confidence intervals for the slope:

lmf = LinearModelFit[data, xvar, xvar, ConfidenceLevel -> .95]; lmf["ParameterConfidenceIntervals"]

The 99% confidence interval is (-1.59, +3.49) in °C/century. Similarly, the 95% confidence interval for the slope is (-0.87, 2.8) in °C/century. On the other hand, the 90% confidence interval is (-0.54, 2.44) in °C/century. All these intervals contain both negative and positive numbers. No conclusion about the slope can be made on either 99%, 95%, and not even 90% confidence level.

Only the 72% confidence interval for the slope touches zero. It means that the probability that the underlying slope is negative equals 1/2 of the rest, i.e. a substantial 14%.

We can only say that it is “somewhat more likely than not” that the underlying trend in 1995-2009 was a warming trend rather than a cooling trend. Saying that the warming since 1995 was “very likely” is already way too ambitious a goal that the data don’t support.

This article was posted: Sunday, December 27, 2009 at 6:22 am

### Share this article

- Recommend on Facebook
- Tweet about it
- Digg this post
- share via Reddit

Comments are closed.

MOST POPULAR

- Report: Three Syrian “Refugees” Rape Little Girl at Knifepoint in Idaho (417 comments)
- Cleveland to Ban Trump Supporters Outside RNC (350 comments)
- ‘Moderate’ Muslim Role Model: ‘Chopping Gays’ Heads Off is the Easiest Solution’ (344 comments)
- UN Demands Bigger, Stronger UN “Police” Force (315 comments)
- Loretta Lynch Admits That Federal Authorities Have Lost The Orlando Shooter’s Wife (282 comments)

- Wednesday: The Infowars Nightly News. Trump's Clinton Clobbering Speech
- Wednesday: The Alex Jones Show. Trump Outs Hillary As A World-Class Liar
- Tuesday: The Nightly News. Clinton Foundation Exposed In Latest Hack
- Tuesday: The Alex Jones Show. Left-Wing Windup Toy Makes An Assassination Attempt On Trump

- Monday: The Infowars Nightly News. Terror Threats Abound US Steps Up The Police State
- Monday: The Alex Jones Show. Lewandowski Out!
- Sunday: The Alex Jones Show. Brexit Could Break Apart NATO
- Friday: The Alex Jones Show. Terror Watch List Dismantles Due Process / Labor Politicizes MP Death / Smartmatic Votes Hillary

- Thursday: The Infowars Nightly News. Is The Us Reeling Towards Complete Chaos In 2016?
- Thursday: The Alex Jones Show. Drudge To DHS Secretary: Give Up Your Guns First!
- Wednesday: The Infowars Nightly News.The Gun Grabbing Train Builds Steam,While The DNC Loses It's Playbook
- Wednesday: The Alex Jones Show. Infowars Analysis Confirmed - Globalist Allied With Radical Islam To Destroy The West: Emergency Transmission

- Tuesday: The Infowars Nightly News. The American Jihad Is Now A Reality For US Citizens
- Tuesday: The Alex Jones Show. Saudi Arabia Has Paid Off The US Goverment
- Monday: The Infowars Nightly News. Is Gun Control Legislation Really The Mass Murderer?
- Monday: The Alex Jones Show. Left Chooses To Blame Second Amendment, Not Radical Islam

- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5

RSS FEEDS

Alex Jones Podcast

©** 2016 PrisonPlanet.com** is a **Free Speech Systems, LLC company**. All rights reserved. Digital Millennium Copyright Act Notice.