HomeRadioTelevisionLocal ContactSearchHelp
Monday, 08-Mar-04 16:26:23 PST

Supreme Court says B.C. school board wrong to ban same-sex books
Last Updated Fri, 20 Dec 2002 22:13:35

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada ruled Friday that a British Columbia school board should not have banned books at the kindergarten and Grade 1 level that depicted same-sex parents.

In a 7-2 ruling, the top court said the school board in Surrey went against provincial legislation that says the public school system is secular and non-sectarian.

The case goes back to 1997, when the school board refused to approve three books for use in kindergarten and Grade 1.

The three books are Asha's Mums, Belinda's Bouquet and One Dad, Two Dads, Brown Dads, Blue Dads. The books depicted same-sex parents in a favourable light, triggering complaints from parents who took objection on religious grounds.

James Chamberlain, a primary-level teacher, wanted to use the books in class, even though they are not part of a reading list approved by the B.C. Education Ministry.

The Supreme Court ruling focused on the religious objections, rather than the larger issue of gay and lesbian constitutional rights.

The Surrey board said it ordered the ban because the books were not suitable for five- and six-year olds. The board also said many parents objected to the books because they regard homosexuality as a sin.

John Fisher

But the court said the moral objections of some parents are not a basis for a ban. The court also concluded "tolerance is always age-appropriate," said John Fisher of the group Equality for Gays and Lesbians Everywhere.

"The Supreme Court of Canada today ruled that learning about difference actually enhances children's education, that kids benefit when they learn respect for those who are different," he said.

A trial judge supported Chamberlain in 1998; then the B.C. Court of Appeal reversed the decision in 2000. The appeal court ruled the board could exclude the books from the classroom but have them available in the school library.

Written by CBC News Online staff

H e a d l i n e s : C a n a d a

Terms of Use | Privacy | Copyright | Other Policies
Copyright CBC 2003

VIDEO: Terry Milewski reports for CBC TV
(Runs 2:22)Captioned

Chris Brown reports for CBC Radio
(Runs 1:17)


Surry School Board comments about the ruling against its ban on books depicting gay parents
(Runs 8:01)

Newsworld'sDavid Gray speaks with John Fisher about the Supreme Court decision about banning same sex books
(Runs )

Newsworld's Nancy Wilson gets an update from CBC's Alan Waterman.
(Runs 3:38)

Newsworld's Nancy Wilson talks with Joseph Arvay, the winning lawyer in the case.
(Runs 7:13)

Mary Polack of the Surrey School Board comments on the cost of the lawsuit.
(Runs :40)

(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)

Send your comments to mailto:letters@cbc.ca?subject=RE:Supreme Court says B.C. school board wrong to ban same-sex books

Share your thoughts on this and other news stories!

Email This Story
Printable Version