Fans of Theodore Dalrymple
April 20, 2018
The doctor-writer’s diagnosis of the deep German psychopathology — and why the rest of us always end up paying a heavy price for it
Dalrymple writes that a healthy patriotism
seems to be denied to Germany. The historical reasons for this are perfectly obvious, of course. But it is more difficult to rid oneself of pride than one might think: one can become proud of one’s lack of pride.
When Angela Merkel agreed to take more than a million migrants,
it was easy in her gesture to see her desire to restore the moral reputation of her nation.
One motive touted,
that with its ageing and declining population, Germany needed more young labour, is absurd: there are millions of unemployed young Spaniards, Italians and Greeks on its doorstep who could have been absorbed with much less difficulty.
Still the bully
The problem arises when Germany,
newly proud of its openness to refugees, tries to make other countries suffer the consequences of its policy, in the name of some kind of abstract principle. Thus other countries, such as Hungary, are to be bullied into taking refugees or face hostility and ostracism. (No one asks the refugees themselves whether they want to be resettled in Hungary. They are abstractions in the European psychodrama, not people of flesh and blood, with desires and ambitions of their own.)
The desire of the Germans
to overcome or dissolve their German-ness in the tepid bath of European Union-ness is the consequence of a certain historiography in which all of German history is but a run-up to Nazism: in other words that Nazism is immanent in the German soul, and the only way to control it is to tie it down as Gulliver was. But this supposed need does not exist to anything like the same extent in other countries, which may nevertheless be constrained by German power, influence and financial might to follow suit. The key to contemporary Europe may perhaps be found in the character of Uriah Heep.
This article was posted: Friday, April 20, 2018 at 6:38 am